by Becky Bernstein
Energy drinks... Is it really energy they offer?
It seems wise to read the ingredients and nutritional info, but is that giving you a true picture? This short article has some answers...Not all energy drinks are regulated the same. In fact, manufacturers are given considerable discretion when classifying how their products are regulated by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Energy drinks classified as beverages (look for the label: “Nutritional Facts") are subject to stricter safety regulation.pertaining to the amount, types and combinations of caffeine and other additives used; while those classified as liquid dietary supplements (look for the label: “Supplement Facts”) operate under more lenient rules.
Energy Drinks Classified as Beverages (e.g., Red Bull)
If an energy drink is classified as a “beverage”, its ingredients must be deemed “generally recognized as safe” (GRAS) for human consumption. In determining this, the FDA considers not only the ingredients used, but also the amounts added to the drink. For example, caffeine added to beverages is considered “safe” up to levels of roughly 70 mg per 12 ounce drink (e.g., 200 parts per million). As long as ingredients used are deemed safe (GRAS), FDA approval is not required.
Energy Drinks Classified as Supplements (e.g., Monster)
If an energy drink is classified as a “supplement”, its ingredients do not fall under the GRAS standards. Instead, it’s up to the manufacturer to submit their own research to show the safety of ingredients. These drinks may contain unproven levels of otherwise safe additives, such as caffeine. They may also contain unproven additives – those that have not been tested by the FDA to determine safety.
The FDA can only restrict Supplements if they can demonstrate the ingredients present an unreasonable risk of illness or injury. Such review efforts may not be taken by the FDA unless they decide to act on reported incidents of adverse effects caused by the drinks. It’s interesting to note that manufacturers of supplements are required to report incidents of adverse effects to the FDA, while beverage manufacturers are not.
Caffeine Levels Reported in Energy Drinks
Caffeine levels are not required to be disclosed on product labels. According to the FDA website, this is because dietary information is only required to be disclosed for nutrients; and caffeine is not a nutrient. It is a natural chemical found in such items as tea leaves, coffee beans, and cacao.
Some manufacturers do disclose caffeine levels voluntarily. In fact, a recent Consumer Reports study found that 16 of the 27 most popular energy drinks reported the levels of caffeine, although in some cases the amounts reported were confusing (because of differences in serving sizes); and in some cases the amounts reported were inaccurate, with caffeine in five of the drinks understated by more than 20%.
Everything in Moderation
Future Energy Drink Regulation
Late last year the FDA said it would consider whether new labeling requirements and health warnings on caffeinated energy drinks are warranted. They are also working on final rules for what qualifies as a beverage versus a dietary supplement. These efforts are taking place as investigations into deaths linked to 5-hour Energy and Monster Energy Drinks are being conducted.
It should also be noted that Monster recently announced it would begin labeling the caffeine content on its energy drinks to provide better information to its customers.
Energy Drink Awareness
As reports of energy drink hospitalizations and deaths continue, what are your thoughts – on the manufacturers, the consumers, the FDA? It is your body check the facts!